Bill Gray’s Restaurant Menu and Price List

A Bill Gray’s order has the feel of a Rochester lunch counter with the volume turned up. A cheeseburger lands on a fresh roll, hot sauce waits nearby, fries spill across the tray, and a Great Plate sits heavy enough to stop conversation for a few bites. The menu is built around comfort food that does not pretend to be delicate. It is burgers, hot dogs, chicken sandwiches, fish fry, wings, fries, kids meals, and cold drinks, with Abbott’s frozen custard at many shops.

This Bill Gray’s restaurant menu and price list uses the public Bill Gray’s Gates order menu at 2987 Buffalo Road, Rochester, NY 14624. Bill Gray’s has many New York locations, so the final price can change by shop, pickup, delivery, app fee, coupon, or order change. Use this as a sample price guide before you order, then check your nearest Bill Gray’s if you need the exact total.

High-End Picks for a Bill Gray’s-Style Burger Night at Home

For readers who want to build a serious burger-and-fries setup at home, start with gear that can take heat and repeat orders. A commercial flat-top griddle over $2,000 can handle burgers, hot dogs, onions, chicken, sausage, and steak sandwiches with a steady sear. A double-basket commercial fryer over $2,000 can cook fries, wings, fish, and tenders with that crisp edge people want from a burger shop. A soft-serve or frozen custard machine over $2,000 can bring the Abbott’s-style finish to a home party. You can browse Amazon with this affiliate tag: commercial flat-top griddles over $2,000, commercial double-basket fryers over $2,000, and commercial soft-serve machines over $2,000.

Bill Gray’s Menu Overview

Bill Gray’s is best known for its cheeseburgers. The brand uses the phrase Home of the World’s Greatest Cheeseburger, and the burger section backs that up with many versions of the same main idea: ground steak on a fresh Di Paolo roll with cheese, bacon, mushrooms, bleu cheese, barbecue sauce, or a double patty. The burger menu is the first place most diners look.

The menu also carries Rochester-area comfort food. Zweigle’s red and white hot dogs sit in the sandwich section. Great Plates bring cheeseburgers or tenders over two side items with a dinner roll and butter. Fish fry appears under seafood. Wings and chicken tenders round out the fried side. Fries, pickles, sauces, and drinks finish the order like small hinges on a heavy door.

At the Gates shop on the public order page, burger prices start at $8.39 for the Ground Steak Burger and reach $18.09 for the Bubba Double Bacon Cheeseburger. Sandwiches run from $8.89 for hot dogs to $12.09 for Philly Sliced Steak & Cheese. Cheeseburger Plate costs $18.39. A 6-piece bar wing order costs $11.39. Chicken Tender Plate costs $18.39. Kids Chicken Tenders Meal is $11.89. Bill’s Famous Haddock Fish Fry costs $21.89, and regular French fries cost $6.79.

Bill’s Famous Burgers Prices

The burger section is the heart of Bill Gray’s. Each burger can be built with toppings, which is part of the fun. The standard cheeseburger has two slices of American cheese. The Ground Steak Burger strips things down to the beef and roll. Bacon, mushrooms, honey barbecue, and bleu cheese bring more character to the burger without leaving the core Bill Gray’s style.

The lowest burger price is the Ground Steak Burger at $8.39. The classic order is the World’s Greatest Cheeseburger at $9.99. Bacon lovers will likely move to Bacon Cheeseburger or Honey BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger at $12.49. The Bubba Double Bacon Cheeseburger is the heavy order, a burger built like a brick wall with bacon in the mortar.

Sandwiches and Hot Dogs

The sandwich section brings in hot dogs, sausage, chicken, and steak. Bill Gray’s uses Zweigle’s hot dogs, a Rochester favorite with a snap and a salty bite. The red hot and white hot both cost $8.89 on the Gates delivery page. Chicken sandwiches sit at $10.39, while Philly Sliced Steak & Cheese is the highest sandwich price shown at $12.09.

For a Rochester-style order, the white hot is a strong pick. For a chicken meal, the crispy Buffalo version gives more bite than the plain crispy fillet. Philly Sliced Steak & Cheese is the fuller sandwich, with steak, peppers, onions, cheese, and bread working together like a small grill party packed into a roll.

Great Plates Prices

Great Plates are Bill Gray’s version of the Rochester plate tradition. A base of two side items gets topped with cheeseburgers or chicken tenders, then finished with toppings and sauce. The Gates menu notes that the Cheeseburger Plate comes with a dinner roll and butter. The public page also shows Chicken Tender Plate and Buffalo Chicken Tender Plate in search text tied to the same Gates menu.

The Cheeseburger Plate is one of the most filling meals on the menu. It is not only a burger meal. It is two small cheeseburgers sitting over sides, with sauce and a roll nearby. It has the mood of late-night Rochester food, even when ordered in the middle of the day.

Bar Wings and Chicken Tenders

Bill Gray’s also serves bone-in bar wings and chicken tenders. The Gates page lists 6-piece Bar Wings at $11.39 and describes wings as bone-in pieces tossed in sauce. Chicken tenders appear in plate form and on the kids menu. Wings and tenders are the best path for someone at the table who does not want a burger.

A 6-piece wing order is a strong snack or side order. A chicken tender plate is a full meal because it comes over two sides. The kids tender meal costs less, but it is still not tiny. It comes with a side and a drink, which helps when feeding children who want something familiar.

Seafood Menu Prices

Seafood is led by Bill’s Famous Haddock Fish Fry. The Gates order page lists it at $21.89 and says it comes with any two sides. The fish fry is a Rochester staple, especially on Fridays, and Bill Gray’s keeps it on the menu as a full dinner plate rather than a small sandwich.

The fish fry is the highest clearly listed price in this guide. It costs more than many burger and sandwich orders, but it also includes two sides. For diners who came for fish rather than beef, it is the main seafood plate to watch.

Side Orders and Condiments

French fries are one of the key side orders at Bill Gray’s. The Gates menu lists regular French fries at $6.79. The order page also has a condiments section, with dill pickles shown at $0.45. Hot sauce, pickles, and other small add-ons can make a burger or plate taste much more like Bill Gray’s.

Fries are the easiest add-on, but the hot sauce is the flavor many fans remember. It is thick, meaty, and spicy in a way that feels tied to Western New York. It can turn a plain burger into something with a little thunder under the hood.

Kids Meals

Kids meals on the Gates menu come with a side and a choice of small soda, milk, or apple juice. The public page shows Kids Chicken Tenders Meal at $11.89 and search text also shows Kids Cheeseburger Meal and Kids Hot Dog Meal. Prices for each child meal can shift by item and order platform.

Beverages and Abbott’s Frozen Custard

The Gates order page lists a beverages category, and the main Bill Gray’s site notes that many locations serve Abbott’s. That matters because Bill Gray’s and Abbott’s often sit together in the same food memory for Rochester diners: burger first, frozen custard after. Drink and custard prices can change by flavor, size, shop, and add-ons, so confirm them during checkout.

Coupons and Online Ordering Notes

Bill Gray’s has an official coupon page and an official order page. The coupon page can change, but it often lists deals tied to cheeseburgers, Great Plates, fountain beverages, and online promo codes. Since coupons can be time-limited, the best move is to check the coupon page before checkout. A small deal can pull the meal back down, especially when ordering for a family.

The official order page lists many Bill Gray’s shops, including Brockport, Chili, Gates, Latta Road, North Greece Road, Henrietta, Irondequoit, Ontario, Penfield, Port of Rochester, Seabreeze, and Webster. Store hours and menu items can shift by site. Gates on the public delivery page shows daily ordering from 11:00 a.m. to 8:30 p.m., while some official location pages list later Friday and Saturday hours for other shops.

Best Picks by Budget

For the lowest burger spend, Ground Steak Burger at $8.39 is the best fit. For the classic Bill Gray’s order, World’s Greatest Cheeseburger at $9.99 gives the name-brand experience without bacon, mushrooms, or double meat. For a bigger burger, Bubba Double Cheeseburger costs $15.69, and Bubba Double Bacon Cheeseburger costs $18.09.

For hot dogs, both the red hot and white hot cost $8.89 at the Gates order page. That price is higher than a plain snack stand dog, but these are quarter-pound Zweigle’s hot dogs served on Di Paolo rolls. For chicken, the grilled, crispy, and Buffalo chicken sandwiches all cost $10.39. For steak, the Philly Sliced Steak & Cheese costs $12.09.

For a full plate, Cheeseburger Plate at $18.39 gives one of the heaviest meals. Chicken Tender Plate costs the same. Fish fry costs more at $21.89, but it includes two sides. If the table is sharing, a burger with fries can be simpler. If one diner wants a full Rochester plate, Great Plates are the better fit.

How to Order at Bill Gray’s

A good first order is the World’s Greatest Cheeseburger with fries and hot sauce. It gives the core flavor in one tray. Add pickles if you want more bite. Choose the Plate Burger if you want fries and mac salad right on top of the burger. Choose the Cheeseburger Plate if you want the Rochester plate experience with two side items.

For non-burger diners, the red hot or white hot gives a local flavor. Crispy Buffalo Chicken Fillet Sandwich is a strong choice for someone who wants spice. Philly Sliced Steak & Cheese is the better pick for a heavier sandwich. Bill’s Famous Haddock Fish Fry is the seafood order, especially when you want a full dinner rather than a sandwich.

Location and Contact for the Priced Menu

The priced menu used here is for Bill Gray’s Gates at 2987 Buffalo Road, Rochester, NY 14624. The official location list gives the Gates phone number as 585-247-3940. The public delivery page lists the Gates shop as Bill Gray’s Gates and shows it open for ordering every day from 11:00 a.m. to 8:30 p.m. Local hours can change, so check the location page before driving over.

Bottom Line on Bill Gray’s Menu Prices

Bill Gray’s restaurant menu and price list is built around burgers, hot dogs, chicken, plates, fish fry, sides, and custard. On the Gates public order page, burgers range from $8.39 to $18.09. Sandwiches run from $8.89 to $12.09. Cheeseburger Plate and Chicken Tender Plate cost $18.39. Bar Wings start at $11.39 for 6 pieces. Kids Chicken Tenders Meal costs $11.89. Bill’s Famous Haddock Fish Fry costs $21.89. Regular French fries cost $6.79.

The menu works best when you lean into what Bill Gray’s does well. Order the cheeseburger when you want the classic. Order a Great Plate when hunger is loud. Order the fish fry when you want a Friday-night plate without cooking. Add hot sauce when the food needs a spark. Bill Gray’s is a burger shop with Rochester roots, a roll full of beef, a tray full of fries, and a sauce cup waiting like a little red warning light.