Bennigan’s Restaurant Menu and Price List

A Bennigan’s meal has the feel of a pub table after a long day. There is a basket of fries in the middle, a tall sandwich on one plate, ribs on another, and a dessert that looks like it was built for more than one spoon. The menu is casual, loud in the best way, and full of comfort food with Irish-American flavor. It is the kind of food that does not whisper. It walks in with melted cheese, fried batter, barbecue sauce, smoky honey Dijon, and a powdered-sugar Monte Cristo.

This Bennigan’s restaurant menu and price list is a sample guide for diners who want to check prices before ordering. Bennigan’s states that menu items and prices can vary by location, so the numbers below should be treated as sample prices rather than a fixed national price list. The priced examples come from public Bennigan’s On The Fly menus in Wichita, Kansas and Coralville, Iowa, plus delivery menu prices where noted. Your local Bennigan’s may charge more, less, or carry a different set of dishes.

High-End Picks for a Bennigan’s-Style Pub Kitchen at Home

For readers who want to bring the Bennigan’s tavern feel into a home game room, pool house, or private bar, start with serious gear. A commercial flat-top griddle over $2,000 can handle burgers, grilled chicken, onions, and sandwiches. A double-basket commercial fryer over $2,000 can cover wings, tenders, fries, and onion rings. A premium kegerator or beer tap system over $2,000 can turn a basement bar into a real gathering spot. You can browse Amazon with this affiliate tag: commercial flat-top griddles over $2,000, double-basket commercial fryers over $2,000, and premium kegerator systems over $2,000.

Bennigan’s Menu Overview

Bennigan’s is known for big American pub food with an Irish accent. The menu has appetizers, wings, soup, salads, burgers, sandwiches, wraps, chicken tenders, ribs, steak, fish, pasta, kids meals, sides, drinks, and desserts. The dishes are built around crispy textures, smoky sauces, melted cheese, warm bread, fried seafood, grilled meat, and sweet finishes. This is not a tiny tasting-menu kind of place. It is a fork-and-napkin restaurant where plates land heavy and the table fills fast.

The World Famous Monte Cristo is one of the best-known Bennigan’s items. It layers honey wheat bread with ham, roasted turkey, Swiss cheese, and American cheese, then gets batter-dipped, fried, dusted with powdered sugar, and served with raspberry preserves. Turkey O’Toole is another long-time favorite, made with turkey breast, melted Swiss, and smoky honey Dijon on a pretzel bun. These two sandwiches give the menu much of its old-school charm.

The price range depends on location. On the sample menus used here, soup starts at $6, appetizers run from about $10.50 to $16.99, sandwiches and burgers sit around $13 to $16, chicken tenders run from $11.99 to $18.99 depending on size and menu type, ribs run from $21 to $34, and desserts range from $8 to $11. Delivery app prices can be higher than dine-in or carryout prices because of app fees and store settings.

Appetizers, Wings, and Starter Prices

Bennigan’s starters are built for sharing. They lean salty, crispy, and saucy, like food made to sit beside cold drinks and sports on a screen. Hogan’s Egg Rolls bring chicken, sweet corn, black beans, and herbs in a fried wrap. Premium Buffalo Wings come with Buffalo sauce, bleu cheese dressing, and celery. Sheela’s Sriracha Shrimp adds a spicy shrimp option. Mozzarella Cheese Sticks and loaded fries fill out the classic bar-food side.

For the best starter value, the soup at $6 is the lowest sample price. Boneless Buffalo Wings at $12.50 work well if the table wants something easy to pass around. The Bites Bundle at $16.99 or more can make sense for a small group because it gives several flavors in one order. Wings are the cleanest choice for a classic pub order, while Hogan’s Egg Rolls feel more tied to Bennigan’s own style.

Salads and Lighter Plates

Bennigan’s salads are not bare bowls of lettuce. They are meal salads with chicken, bacon, cheese, eggs, tomatoes, steak, blue cheese, pecans, apples, or Buffalo-seasoned chicken, depending on the location. The Kilkenny’s Country Chicken Salad is the priced salad found on the On The Fly menus used here. It comes with crispy or grilled chicken, garden greens, bacon, cheese, egg, tomatoes, and smoky honey Dijon dressing.

The Kilkenny’s Country Chicken Salad is the safest salad pick when you want a full meal instead of a side. It still has the Bennigan’s feel because of the bacon, cheese, chicken, and honey Dijon dressing. If your local restaurant carries the Steakhouse Salad, it is the richer pick because of the marinated flat iron steak.

Sandwiches and Wraps Menu Prices

Sandwiches may be the strongest part of the Bennigan’s menu. The Monte Cristo is the famous one, but Turkey O’Toole, the Kilkenny’s Country Chicken Wrap, the Classic Reuben, Bennigan’s Club, and The Original Irish Dip all carry that pub-sandwich personality. Many come with Homestyle French fries, so the plate feels full without adding extra sides.

The Monte Cristo is the plate to order at least once. It is sweet, salty, soft, crisp, and a little wild, like a county fair sandwich wearing a tavern jacket. Turkey O’Toole is better for someone who wants the Bennigan’s flavor without a fried sandwich. The chicken wrap is a good middle ground because it has chicken tenders and bacon, but the wrap keeps it easier to eat.

Burgers Menu Prices

Bennigan’s burgers are half-pound pub burgers at many sit-down locations. They are often served with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, and Homestyle French fries. The official burger lineup can include the Classic Burger, BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger, Spicy Chipotle Burger, Guinness Glazed Bacon Burger, The B.O.M.B. Burger, St. Brigid Burger, and the Irishman Whiskey Glazed Burger. The priced sample menus show The B.O.M.B. Burger and Classic Cheeseburger.

The Classic Cheeseburger is the cleanest price comparison because it lands at $14.99 or more on the delivery menu. The B.O.M.B. Burger costs a little more on the Coralville menu, and it has a bigger flavor from bacon jam and fried onions. If your local Bennigan’s carries the Guinness Glazed Bacon Burger, expect a richer, sweeter, darker sauce profile.

Chicken, Ribs, and Main Plate Prices

The main plates move from fried chicken tenders to ribs, steak, fish, salmon, pork chops, and pasta. The priced On The Fly menus give clear numbers for Chicken Tenders and Oh, Baby Back Ribs. The broader Bennigan’s menu can also include Danny Boy Chicken, Char-Grilled Flat Iron Steak, Finn’s Beer-Battered Fish and Chips, Grilled Salmon Fillet, Cajun Chicken and Shrimp Pasta, Passion Fruit Glazed Pork Chop, and Irishman Whiskey Glazed Chicken. Those prices should be checked at the local restaurant.

The ribs are the highest-priced sample item here, reaching $34 for a full rack in Wichita and $31 in Coralville. Chicken tenders are more flexible because some menus sell them as a platter, while delivery menus price them by piece count. If you want the most filling order from the sample list, a full rack of ribs is the heavy plate. If you want a lower price with fries included, the 3 Piece Chicken Tenders at $11.99 or more is the smaller order.

Wing Count Prices

Some delivery menus list wings by count. This helps when you are comparing a solo snack with a meal-sized order. Prices below may rise with sauce choices, add-ons, and app fees.

The six-piece boneless wings are the lowest-priced wing order in this sample. Bone-in wings cost more at each count. That is common for delivery menus, especially when chicken prices move. For sharing, the eight-piece or ten-piece orders usually make more sense than ordering two small boxes.

Sides Menu Prices

Most Bennigan’s plates already come with fries, but sides can turn a sandwich into a more filling meal. The delivery sample menu lists several fry styles and onion rings. These prices often change more on delivery apps than in dining rooms.

Cheese Fries are the lowest-priced listed side at $5.99 or more. Bacon Ranch Fries cost a bit more and add a smoky ranch flavor. Onion rings are the better match for burgers if you want a change from fries.

Dessert Menu Prices

Bennigan’s desserts are not shy. Brownie Bottom Pie is a warm, rich favorite with a chewy brownie, vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry. Death by Chocolate is the bigger chocolate order, made with chocolate ice cream, almonds, marshmallows, fudge sauce, candy bar pieces, cookie crust, chocolate shell, and hot chocolate topping. New York Cheesecake gives a calmer finish with strawberry sauce.

Brownie Bottom Pie is the best dessert value from the priced menus, especially when priced at $8. Death by Chocolate costs more, but it feels like the big finish for a table that wants to share. Cheesecake is the safer choice for someone who wants dessert without a full chocolate storm.

Kids Menu

The Bennigan’s kids menu is for children 12 and younger at many locations. The official kids menu includes a drink with the meal, though bottled soft drinks are excluded. Kids entrée choices can include Chicken Tenders, Burger Bites with Cheese, Grilled Cheese, Jr. Kilkenny’s Salad, Nathan’s Slider Dogs, Grilled Shrimp, Grilled Chicken Tenders, and Jr. Kilkenny’s Grilled Chicken Salad. Sweet treats can include Cookies and Cream Dream, a kid shake, or a Cherries Jubilee Shake. Prices were not shown in the priced sample pages used here, so check your nearest shop before ordering for children.

Best Value Picks at Bennigan’s

For a low-cost start, Ultimate Baked Potato Soup at $6 is the easiest pick. It gives that thick, warm pub feel without jumping into a full entrée. For an appetizer to share, Boneless Buffalo Wings at $12.50 or Hogan’s Egg Rolls at $10.50 to $13.99 or more give more table energy. If the group wants a little bit of everything, the Bennigan’s Bites Bundle at $16.99 or more may be worth the higher price.

For sandwiches, Turkey O’Toole at $13 to $13.50 is one of the better sample prices. The Monte Cristo at $15 is worth trying because it is the dish many people connect with Bennigan’s. For burgers, the Classic Cheeseburger at $14.99 or more is the plain comparison point, while The B.O.M.B. Burger at $15.50 adds more flavor for a small price bump.

For dinner plates, the 3 Piece Chicken Tenders at $11.99 or more offer the lowest sample price in the chicken group. A half rack of ribs at $21 to $23 costs more but brings a fuller plate with fries and coleslaw. The full rack at $31 to $34 is the splurge order. It is best when you arrive hungry or want leftovers.

How to Order From Bennigan’s

If you are new to Bennigan’s, start with the Monte Cristo. It is the sandwich that gives the clearest taste of the brand. Add potato soup if you want a warm, creamy starter. Choose ribs or chicken tenders when you want a plate built around fries and sauce. Choose Kilkenny’s Country Chicken Salad when you want greens but still want bacon, cheese, egg, and chicken.

For a group, build the table around starters and one or two big plates. Wings, Hogan’s Egg Rolls, cheese sticks, and loaded fries can cover the first round. Then add Monte Cristos, burgers, ribs, or chicken tenders based on appetite. For dessert, Brownie Bottom Pie is the easier share, while Death by Chocolate is the big spoon-fight plate.

Final Take on Bennigan’s Menu Prices

The Bennigan’s restaurant menu and price list changes by location, but the sample prices give a useful look at the likely range. Soup starts at $6. Appetizers and wings often sit between about $10.50 and $16.99. Sandwiches, wraps, salads, and burgers often land around $13 to $16. Chicken tenders range from $11.99 to $18.99 depending on size and order type. Ribs are higher, from about $21 for a half rack to $34 for a full rack. Desserts range from $8 to $11 in the sample menus.

Bennigan’s is best when you lean into what it does well: hot sandwiches, fried starters, saucy ribs, crisp chicken, loaded sides, and big desserts. The menu is not trying to be quiet. It is a green-and-gold pub table with powdered sugar on one plate, barbecue sauce on another, and fries waiting in the middle like everyone already agreed to share.