Bella Pizza Restaurant Menu and Price List

Bella Pizza is the kind of place people picture when they want a hot box on the table, a thin slice that folds in the hand, and cheese that stretches like a little rope from plate to mouth. The menu is built for easy cravings: whole pies, specialty pizza, breadsticks, calzones, pizza rolls, pasta, salads, kids’ meals, and desserts. It feels casual, warm, and direct. No stiff dinner mood. No maze of tiny plates. Just pizza shop food with enough choice to feed one hungry person or a whole table.

This Bella Pizza restaurant menu and price list is based on the public menu for Bella Pizzeria, which has locations at Clay Terrace in Carmel, Indiana, and Hamilton Town Center in Noblesville, Indiana. Prices can change by location, order method, size, toppings, and delivery app fees, so treat this guide as a close planning sheet before you order.

High-End Picks After the First Look

The priciest pizza on the listed menu is the 18-inch extra-large meat stuffed pizza at $32.99. It comes with double sausage, double pepperoni, and double mozzarella. It is the pizza version of a padded winter coat: heavy, full, and made for a serious appetite. For a big table, that stuffed pie is the top premium pick.

Among the specialty pies, The Bella, Barbecue Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, Meat Lover’s, and Deluxe all reach $28.50 for an extra-large. The Bella is the house-name pie with hot Italian sausage, roasted red peppers, fresh garlic, pepperoni, red onions, and mozzarella. Meat Lover’s is the best pick for anyone who wants a salty, smoky bite in every slice. Barbecue Chicken and Buffalo Chicken are better for guests who want a sauce-forward pizza with roasted chicken and melted cheese.

Quick View of Bella Pizza Prices

The menu starts with a cheese pizza at $14.49 for large and $18.99 for extra-large. Standard toppings cost $1.85 for large and $2.25 for extra-large. Premium toppings cost $2.25 for large and $2.95 for extra-large. Specialty pizzas range from $17.99 to $20.45 for large and $23.99 to $28.50 for extra-large. Breadsticks begin at $2.49 for two plain sticks, while calzones and pizza rolls are listed at $11.49 each. Pasta plates run from $6.99 to $10.99 and come with three garlic knots. Salads run from $3.49 to $11.49. Kids’ meals stay under $6, and desserts sit between $2.49 and $4.49.

This is a menu where the best deal depends on appetite. One person can eat well with a pasta plate, a calzone, or a few breadsticks. A family will get more from a large or extra-large pizza, especially if everyone agrees on toppings. A party table should look at extra-large specialty pies, garlic knots, and salads. The menu works like a toolbox: small pieces for a fast bite, bigger pieces for a full night.

Bella Pizza Whole Pizza Prices

The plain cheese pie is the base of the Bella Pizza menu. It is also the easiest price anchor. A large cheese pizza costs $14.49, while an extra-large costs $18.99. From there, the bill rises with toppings. The standard topping charge is lower, which makes pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, green peppers, and spinach easier to add without sending the total too high. Premium toppings cost more because they include richer meats and cheeses.

For a simple order, a large cheese pizza with one standard topping lands at $16.34 before tax or fees. An extra-large cheese pizza with one standard topping lands at $21.24. A large pie with one premium topping lands at $16.74, and an extra-large with one premium topping lands at $21.94. These small differences matter when a table builds several pies at once.

Bella Pizza Specialty Pizza Menu

The specialty pizza section is the heart of the menu. The Bella is the house order, and it has the boldest mix of meat, garlic, peppers, onions, and cheese. Margherita is softer and cleaner, with sliced tomatoes, basil, romano, mozzarella, and garlic butter sauce. White pizza skips red sauce and leans into ricotta, romano, mozzarella, and black pepper. Hawaiian gives the sweet-and-salty ham and pineapple mix. Veggie Supreme keeps meat off the pie but still feels full because of mushrooms, peppers, onions, spinach, tomatoes, and mozzarella.

The chicken pizzas bring stronger sauce personalities. Barbecue Chicken tastes sweet, smoky, and cheesy. Buffalo Chicken tastes hotter and sharper from Frank’s hot sauce. Meat Lover’s is built for people who want the slice to feel packed from crust to tip. Deluxe sits between meat and vegetables, which makes it one of the safer group choices.

Stuffed Pizza and Gluten-Free Pizza

The stuffed pizza is the most expensive single pizza on the menu. It is only listed in the 18-inch extra-large size, so it suits a group better than a solo meal. The gluten-free cheese pizza is listed only in a 10-inch size. That makes it useful for one guest who needs that crust option while the rest of the table orders a standard large or extra-large pie.

Toppings and Premium Toppings

The topping list gives guests plenty of room to build a custom pizza. Pepperoni sits in the standard group, which helps keep a classic pepperoni pie affordable. Bacon, ham, sausage, roasted chicken, and extra cheeses sit in the premium group. A good custom order for meat lovers is cheese pizza with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon. A good vegetable order is mushrooms, green peppers, red onions, and fresh garlic. For a bright, spicy bite, pick jalapeños with red onions and banana peppers.

Breadsticks and Dipping Sauces

Breadsticks are the easiest add-on. Plain breadsticks come topped with butter and parsley. Pepperoni breadsticks add meat and garlic salt. Cheezy Weezy breadsticks pile on mozzarella, cheddar, and romano. Garlic knots are hand-tied and tossed with garlic butter, garlic salt, and parsley. Every two breadsticks, or every five garlic knots, come with one two-ounce sauce. Sauce choices include nacho cheese, garlic butter, marinara, and ranch. Extra sauce costs $0.65 each.

For a low-cost side, garlic knots are hard to beat. Ten knots cost $6.50 and can stretch across a table. For a richer snack, Cheezy Weezy breadsticks cost more, but they bring three cheeses and feel closer to a small meal.

Calzones and Pizza Rolls

All calzones and pizza rolls are served with a side of marinara sauce. The $11.49 flat price makes this section easy to order from. The ham and cheese calzone is the mildest option. Stromboli is the busiest, with ham, sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and mozzarella. Panzerotti is the boldest meat pick because it doubles the sausage, pepperoni, and mozzarella. The spinach roll is softer and creamier, and the chicken roll keeps things simple with roasted chicken and mozzarella.

Pasta Menu Prices

Pasta gives Bella Pizza a softer dinner side. Each pasta dish comes with three garlic knots, which helps the plate feel fuller. Pasta and sauce is the lowest-price pasta at $6.99. Baked ziti and spaghetti with meatballs both cost $9.49. Meat lasagna costs $10.99 and is the top pasta price. Add-ons cost $2.29 each, so a plain pasta and sauce can turn into a bigger plate with meatballs, sausage, or roasted chicken.

Baked ziti is the best comfort pick because ricotta, marinara, and mozzarella melt into the penne. Spaghetti with meatballs is the classic. Meat lasagna is heavier and better for a slow dinner. Pasta and sauce works for kids, light appetites, and anyone who wants a cheaper meal with warm knots on the side.

Salads, Kids’ Meals, and Desserts

The salad section is short but useful. A side salad at $3.49 can balance pizza and breadsticks. Greek salad costs $8.49 and brings cucumbers, feta, and kalamata olives. Antipasto salad costs $11.49 and eats more like a full plate because it adds ham, salami, pepperoni, olives, peppers, onions, and mozzarella. Dressings include homemade Italian, homemade ranch, homemade balsamic vinaigrette, French, and Greek. Extra dressing costs $0.65 each.

The kids’ meals are some of the lowest-cost complete orders on the menu. Both include a 16-ounce fountain drink. Kids’ pasta and sauce costs $4.89, while kids’ spaghetti and meatball costs $5.85. Dessert prices stay modest. A homemade cookie is $2.49, cheesecake brownie is $2.75, and cannoli is $4.49.

Best Bella Pizza Orders by Budget

For the lowest-cost solo meal, kids’ pasta will only work for a child, but adults can still keep things cheap with pasta and sauce at $6.99 or a small tossed salad with breadsticks. For a better solo meal, order a calzone or pizza roll at $11.49. That price gets you filling, bread, cheese, and marinara in one neat package.

For two people, a large cheese pizza at $14.49 plus garlic knots at $3.25 keeps the meal simple. Add one standard topping and the pizza becomes $16.34. For a family, an extra-large specialty pizza makes more sense. The Margherita extra-large is $23.99, while most of the meaty extra-large specialty pies cost $28.50. Add ten garlic knots and the total becomes more table-friendly without adding another whole pizza.

For the biggest order, choose the 18-inch meat stuffed pizza at $32.99, an antipasto salad at $11.49, and ten garlic knots at $6.50. That meal has heavy cheese, meat, greens, garlic, and marinara. It is not quiet food. It lands on the table like a drumbeat.

Best Bella Pizza Orders by Taste

If you want a classic pizza shop taste, get cheese pizza with pepperoni or Meat Lover’s. If you want something brighter, choose Margherita. If you want a creamy pie without red sauce, pick White. If you want heat, Buffalo Chicken is the clear choice. If you want the house-name option, The Bella gives you hot Italian sausage, roasted red peppers, garlic, pepperoni, onions, and mozzarella in one pie.

For sides, garlic knots are the safe pick. Cheezy Weezy breadsticks are better when the table wants extra cheese before the pizza arrives. Pepperoni breadsticks are the best side for guests who want a snack that already tastes like a tiny rolled pizza. Ranch, marinara, nacho cheese, and garlic butter all change the mood of the bite, so extra sauce can be worth the $0.65.

Final Take on the Bella Pizza Menu

Bella Pizza’s menu is simple in the best way. The prices are easy to follow, the pizza sizes are clear, and the side items fit the main event. The menu gives budget eaters pasta, breadsticks, salads, and kids’ meals, while bigger spenders can move into extra-large specialty pizzas and the meat stuffed pizza. The strongest orders are The Bella, Meat Lover’s, Deluxe, Buffalo Chicken, garlic knots, Cheezy Weezy breadsticks, meat lasagna, and the antipasto salad.

For a fast lunch, get a calzone, pasta, or a simple pizza. For family night, get an extra-large specialty pizza and garlic knots. For the biggest table, order the meat stuffed pizza and add salad so the meal does not feel like cheese and meat alone. Bella Pizza is not a fussy restaurant. It is a hot-slice place with a menu that knows what it wants to be: warm, filling, salty, cheesy, and easy to share.