Barraco’s Pizza Restaurant Menu and Price List

Barraco’s Pizza is the kind of Chicago-area restaurant where the menu feels bigger than the pizza box. A thin crust pie may be the first thing people order, but the kitchen stretches far beyond cheese, sausage, and pepperoni. Deep dish, stuffed pizza, Sicilian pizza, pasta buckets, broasted chicken, Italian beef, steak dinners, seafood, salads, burgers, desserts, and late-night sides all sit under the same roof. It is a pizza place, yes, but it also has the size and appetite of a full Italian-American dinner house.

Barraco’s has several Illinois locations, including Chicago, Evergreen Park, Orland Park, Burbank, and nearby suburbs. Prices can change by store, pickup, delivery app, tax, party order, and limited-time listing. This guide uses live public ordering menus from multiple Barraco’s locations, so some items appear as ranges when one store charges more than another. Use it as a close price map before ordering from your nearest Barraco’s Pizza.

Premium Picks After the First Look

The biggest regular meal prices at Barraco’s Pizza show up in the steak, seafood, rib, chicken bucket, and pasta bucket sections. Surf and Turf Dinner, Petite Filet with Vegetables, and Blue Cheese Crusted NY Strip Steak with Vegetables are often listed at $32.34. These are the top dinner plates, built for guests who want more than pizza or sandwiches.

For group food, the BBQ Chicken Bucket is often listed around $38.34, while the Broasted Chicken Bucket is around $34.74. Pasta buckets also sit in the higher range, with Bucket of Spaghetti and Bucket of Mostaccioli around $31.20, and baked or Alfredo-style buckets around $34.74 to $35.94. For pizza lovers, Mama Barraco Stuffed Pizza at about $27.54 is one of the richest pizza picks, with ricotta, cheese, and spinach tucked into a heavy stuffed crust.

Barraco’s Thin Crust Pizza Prices

Thin crust pizza is the classic Barraco’s order. It is cut for sharing, easy to carry, and built for sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers, pepperoni, bacon, ground beef, fresh tomato, garlic, and giardiniera. The crust has that Chicago tavern-style spirit: thin, crisp, and ready for a busy table.

The best low-price pizza pick is Nicky’s Special at $14.40. It is extra thin, lightly sauced, lightly cheesed, and cooked well done. The Thin Crust Cheese Pizza at $15.00 is the safest first order. Around the World and Meat Special cost more because they carry four toppings. Around the World brings sausage, mushroom, onion, and green pepper, while Meat Special leans heavier with meat toppings.

Deep Dish, Stuffed, and Sicilian Pizza Prices

Barraco’s is not only a thin crust shop. The menu also has deep dish, stuffed pizza, and Sicilian-style pizza. These pizzas cost more than thin crust because they carry more dough, cheese, sauce, and oven time. They land on the table with more weight, like a cast-iron pan compared with a sheet of paper.

Deep Dish Cheese Pizza is a strong middle pick when you want a thicker Chicago-style pie without paying stuffed pizza prices. Sicilian Style Pizza has a thick crust and sweet sauce. Stuffed Cheese Pizza costs more because it adds an extra layer of crust. Mama Barraco Stuffed Pizza is the premium pizza pick here, with ricotta, cheese, and spinach.

Pizza by the Slice Prices

Pizza by the slice works well for a quick lunch, solo meal, or late-night bite. It costs more per serving than buying a whole pizza, but it is useful when one person wants pizza without leftovers.

The slice menu is simple. Cheese, sausage, and pepperoni are usually priced the same. A slice is not the cheapest way to feed a group, but it is one of the easiest ways to quiet a pizza craving.

Appetizer Prices

Barraco’s appetizer menu is large, salty, fried, cheesy, and made for sharing. It has the usual pizza-shop starters, then adds seafood, pan-fried lake perch, baked clams, stuffed artichoke, bruschetta, and pretzel sticks. A table can build half a meal before the pizza even arrives.

Garlic Bread is the best low-cost starter. The Appetizer Plate is a good group choice because it includes cheese sticks, mushrooms, zucchini, and onion rings. Buffalo Wings sit near the top of the starter list, while Fresh Pan-Fried Lake Perch is the premium appetizer for seafood fans.

Salad Prices

The salad menu ranges from a small tossed salad to shrimp Caesar, chef salad, chopped salad, spinach salad, Cobb salad, and antipasto. These are useful when the table has pizza and wings but someone wants greens on the plate too.

The Tossed Salad is the best low-cost salad. The Chopped Salad is one of the fuller meal salads, with grilled chicken, prosciutto, tomatoes, cucumbers, artichoke hearts, mozzarella, gorgonzola, parmesan, and red onion. Shrimp Caesar is the premium salad at $19.20.

Side Order Prices

Barraco’s sides are simple and useful with chicken, steak, pasta, pizza, sandwiches, and ribs. Fries, baked potato, broccoli, rice, soups, side pasta, mashed potatoes, and mac and cheese appear across menus.

Coleslaw is the cheapest side. French fries are the safest add-on for sandwiches and chicken. Side spaghetti or mostaccioli can turn a sandwich order into a fuller Italian meal. Mac and cheese is one of the higher-priced sides, but it brings more comfort than fries.

Hot Sandwich Prices

The hot sandwich menu is large and very Chicago in spirit. Italian beef, Italian sausage, meatball, beef and sausage combo, pepper and egg, chicken parmigiana, veal parmigiana, pork chop, turkey, BLT, subs, and steak sandwiches are all listed. Many of these sandwiches can carry lunch by themselves.

The Italian Beef Sandwich is one of the best Chicago-style picks at $11.40. The Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich is a strong Italian-American order at $11.10. The New York Strip Steak Sandwich is the premium sandwich, priced much higher than the rest of the section.

Burger and Wrap Prices

The burger list is short, simple, and lower priced than most pizza and dinner items. Wraps cost more because they use chicken or steak and eat more like a full lunch.

The Cheeseburger is one of the best low-cost meals on the menu. The Belt Buster Burger is the richer burger choice, served on garlic bread with grilled onion and American cheese. The New York Steak Wrap is the premium wrap, priced above the chicken options.

Chicken Bucket Prices

Chicken buckets are made for groups and family meals. They include chicken, fries, coleslaw, and rolls. They cost more than single dinners, but they give more food and are easier to share.

The Broasted Chicken Bucket is the better value between the two. The BBQ Chicken Bucket costs more but brings a saucier, heavier taste. Both are useful when pizza alone will not feed the table.

Pasta Prices

Barraco’s pasta menu is one of the largest parts of the restaurant. It starts with simple spaghetti and mostaccioli, then adds ravioli, tortellini, lasagna, Alfredo, shrimp, chicken, baked pasta, and specialty plates. Most pasta dishes come with marinara or another sauce, a roll, and parmesan cheese.

Manicotti is one of the lowest-priced pasta choices at $14.40. Spaghetti, mostaccioli, angel hair, fettuccini, and linguine are steady picks at $15.60. Shrimp and veal plates sit near the top. Veal Parmigiana Pasta is the premium pasta item in many listings.

Pasta Bucket Prices

Pasta buckets are made for groups, offices, and family dinners. They cost more upfront, but they stretch better than single bowls when several people are eating.

Bucket of Spaghetti and Bucket of Mostaccioli are the best lower-cost group pasta picks. Alfredo, mac and cheese, and ravioli buckets cost more but feel richer. Pair a pasta bucket with garlic bread and a salad, and dinner is almost done before anyone opens the plates.

House Specialty Dinner Prices

The house specialty section is where Barraco’s becomes more than a pizza place. Chicken, pork chops, steak, ribs, shrimp, salmon, perch, kabobs, and combo dinners all appear here. These plates usually come with a side, fries, and a roll.

Chicken Fingers Dinner and Golden Shrimp Dinner are the lowest-priced full dinner plates. Baby Back Ribs Dinner is a strong middle pick. Surf and Turf, Petite Filet, and Blue Cheese Crusted NY Strip are the top dinner splurges.

Dessert and Ice Cream Prices

The dessert menu has Italian favorites, cakes, pies, brownies, ice cream, gelato, spumoni, and shakes. Cannoli is the low-cost sweet pick, while cake slices and tiramisu sit higher.

The Homemade Cannoli is the best dessert value. Tiramisu is the classic Italian sweet. Spumoni and gelato are good picks after pizza or pasta because they give the meal a cool finish.

Drink Prices

Drink prices on public ordering menus are simple. Soda is usually the cheapest, while iced tea costs a little more.

A soda keeps the meal total low. Water is a simple add-on for pickup orders. Iced tea is the better match with pasta, chicken, and steak dinners.

Best Value Orders at Barraco’s Pizza

For pizza, the best low-cost pick is Thin Crust Nicky’s Special at $14.40. Thin Crust Cheese Pizza at $15.00 is the best classic first order. If you are feeding several people, Around the World, Veggie, or Meat Special at $21.60 gives more toppings without needing to build the pizza one topping at a time.

For appetizers, Garlic Bread at $5.40 and Pizza Bread at $7.20 are the best cheap starters. For a bigger table, the Appetizer Plate at about $16.20 to $16.80 makes sense because it brings several fried snacks in one order. For a fuller meal, Chicken Fingers at $10.80 to $12.00 can stand alone with fries or a side.

For sandwiches, Italian Beef at $11.40, Chicken Parmigiana at $11.10, and Italian Sub at $10.80 are strong lunch picks. For pasta, Spaghetti or Mostaccioli at $15.60 gives a classic plate. For a group, Bucket of Spaghetti or Bucket of Mostaccioli at $31.20 is better than ordering several small pastas.

For dinner, Broasted Chicken Dinner at $19.14, Baby Back Ribs Dinner at $21.54, and Chicken Vesuvio at $23.34 are strong picks. For a splurge, Surf and Turf, Petite Filet, and Blue Cheese Crusted NY Strip all sit at $32.34. These plates cost more, but they turn Barraco’s from pizza night into a full dinner table.

Sample Meal Costs

A solo pizza meal can be as simple as one slice and a soda for about $10.02 before tax. A thin crust cheese pizza with garlic bread can run about $20.40 before tax. A bigger family order with a specialty pizza, wings, and cheesy breadsticks can rise past $50 before drinks, tax, and delivery fees.

Ordering Tips Before You Go

Choose the pizza style first. Thin crust is best for quick sharing. Deep dish is better for a heavier Chicago-style meal. Stuffed pizza is the richest and takes longer. Sicilian Style works when you want thick crust and sweet sauce. If you are ordering for kids, thin crust cheese, sausage, or pepperoni is the easiest path.

For a family, pair one pizza with garlic bread or cheesy breadsticks. For a bigger group, add wings or a pasta bucket. For a full dinner, skip the slice section and look at chicken, ribs, pasta, steak, or seafood. Pickup can cost less than delivery app ordering, so check your local store’s own ordering page before paying.

Final Thoughts on Barraco’s Pizza Menu Prices

Barraco’s Pizza prices start around $1.62 for soda, $4.20 for cannoli, $5.40 for garlic bread, $7.20 for a hamburger or pizza bread, and $8.40 for pizza slices. Whole pizzas often start around $14.40 to $15.00 for thin crust and rise to $27.54 for Mama Barraco Stuffed Pizza. Pasta dishes run from about $14.40 to $22.79, while pasta buckets sit around $31.20 to $35.94. Dinner plates range from about $16.20 to $32.34.

The best first order is Thin Crust Cheese Pizza or Nicky’s Special. The best group order is a specialty thin crust pizza with wings or a pasta bucket. The best sandwich is Italian Beef or Chicken Parmigiana. The best premium dinner is Surf and Turf or Petite Filet. Barraco’s works because it gives Chicago pizza-night comfort, then opens the door to a much bigger table.