Bagelsmith Restaurant Menu and Price List

Bagelsmith is the kind of bagel shop that can pull you in before you even see the counter. A fresh bagel has its own quiet power. It is warm, chewy, and sturdy enough to carry cream cheese, eggs, bacon, lox, turkey, tuna, or a full lunch sandwich without falling apart. At Bagelsmith, the menu reaches past plain bagels and spreads. It covers breakfast sandwiches, omelettes, lox builds, deli sandwiches, hot sandwiches, sides, coffee, juice, smoothies, pastries, and catering packs.

There are Bagelsmith shops in Brooklyn, New York, and there are also Bagelsmith-branded menus in other markets, including Union, New Jersey. Prices can change by location, delivery app, pickup channel, tax, and add-ons. This guide uses public menu pricing from current online ordering pages and delivery menus, then presents the menu as a practical price guide. Use it to plan a breakfast run, lunch order, office tray, or weekend bagel spread before checking the final total with your nearest shop.

Best High-End Picks After the First Look

The highest-priced single sandwiches on Bagelsmith menus tend to be lox sandwiches, specialty sandwiches, large deli builds, and heavy hot sandwiches. At the Brooklyn Lorimer Street menu, the Reuben Specialty Sandwich is listed around $19.25, while specialty sandwiches with chicken cutlet, turkey, grilled eggplant, and other fillings often sit around $17.50 to $18.55. These are not small grab-and-go bites. They are lunch orders with heft, built for someone who wants more than a plain bagel and coffee.

Lox is another premium choice. A fresh lox add-on or lox sandwich can land around $11.50 to $16.15 or higher depending on the location and build. A lox bagel is one of the strongest Bagelsmith picks because it brings the old-school bagel shop flavor: smoked salmon, cream cheese, onion, tomato, capers, and a chewy bagel holding it all together like a small edible plate. For groups, a Smith’s Dozen or bagel pack with spreads can climb into the $23.85 to $34.65 range, while a coffee box can run close to $29.99 at some Brooklyn menus.

Bagelsmith Bagel Prices

Bagels are the base of the Bagelsmith menu. A single bagel is the lowest-cost item in many locations, usually around $1.95 at the Brooklyn Lorimer Street shop and near $1.50 at some other Bagel Smith-style menus. Plain, sesame, poppy, everything, onion, garlic, salt, cinnamon raisin, whole wheat, pumpernickel, egg, and multigrain are common choices. The real choice starts after the bagel: butter, cream cheese, tofu spread, lox spread, or a full sandwich build.

The best low-cost pick is a single bagel or a bagel with butter. The best everyday order is a bagel with cream cheese. It costs more, but it gives the full bagel-shop bite: crisp outside, chewy middle, and a thick spread that softens every corner. Tofu spread is useful for guests who want a non-dairy option, while lox spread gives smoked salmon flavor without paying for a full lox sandwich.

Bulk Bagels and Bagel Pack Prices

Bulk bagels are made for offices, brunch tables, family mornings, and long weekends. A half dozen works for a small group, while a 13-bagel pack or larger spread is better for meetings and parties. Some Bagelsmith shops use names like Smith’s Dozen, Smith’s Half Pack, and The Smith Pack.

A dozen bagels is the better buy when several people are eating. The Smith Pack costs more, but it makes ordering easier when you need bagels and spread together. Add a coffee box, and the order becomes a complete breakfast setup. It is the kind of spread that turns an office counter into a morning campfire, with everyone circling back for one more half bagel.

Spreads and By-the-Pound Prices

Bagelsmith sells spreads and deli salads by portion or by the pound on some menus. This section is useful when you want to build your own bagel tray at home. Prices vary by spread type. Plain cream cheese is lower, while lox spread, whitefish salad, baked salmon salad, and fresh lox cost more.

Plain cream cheese is the safest spread for a group because almost everyone can use it. Veggie cream cheese adds crunch and color. Tofu spread is the best non-dairy-style pick. Whitefish salad and baked salmon salad sit higher because they are richer deli items. Fresh lox is the premium add-on, best saved for a brunch where smoked salmon is the main attraction.

Breakfast Sandwich Prices

Breakfast sandwiches are one of the busiest parts of Bagelsmith’s menu. The build usually starts with egg on a bagel, then adds cheese, bacon, sausage, turkey, avocado, tomato, hash brown, or sauce. A simple egg sandwich is one of the lower-cost hot items. A loaded breakfast sandwich costs more, but it can carry a long morning by itself.

The Egg on a Bagel Sandwich is the best low-cost hot breakfast. The Classic, often built with meat, two eggs, and cheese on a bagel, is a stronger full breakfast. The Bagelsmith Burrito adds hash brown, avocado, egg, cheese, and protein, so it feels heavier than a standard sandwich. The Uptown Lox is the premium breakfast pick, with lox, cream cheese, red onion, tomato, and capers.

Omelettes and Breakfast Platter Prices

Omelettes give Bagelsmith a diner-style side. They are usually served with home fries and toast, which makes them larger than a bagel sandwich. Platters also work well for guests who want pancakes, French toast, eggs, bacon, and a slower breakfast.

The basic omelette is the lowest-cost plate in this section. Three Cheese and Greek omelettes are good middle picks. Meat Lovers Omelette is the premium omelette choice because it brings bacon, sausage, and ham. The French Toast Platter and Pancake Platter are higher-priced breakfast plates because they include more than one breakfast item on the plate.

Lox Specialty Sandwich Prices

Lox sandwiches are a key part of a serious bagel menu. They cost more than egg sandwiches because smoked salmon is the star. A good lox sandwich should feel balanced: salty fish, cool cream cheese, sharp onion, juicy tomato, capers, and a bagel that holds firm from first bite to last.

The best value in this section is lox spread if you want the flavor without the full price. The best full order is a lox sandwich on an everything or plain bagel. It costs more, but it is one of the menu’s signature meals. Lox at Bagelsmith is not a side note. It is the polished silver key on the breakfast ring.

Cold Sandwich Prices

Cold sandwiches turn Bagelsmith into a lunch shop. The choices can include egg salad, tuna salad, chicken salad, turkey, ham, roast beef, pastrami, corned beef, prosciutto, salami, bologna, liver, and whitefish salad. Some orders can be served on a bagel, roll, wrap, rye, or hero-style bread.

Egg salad is the lower-cost deli sandwich pick. Tuna and chicken salad are more filling and often sit around the middle of the lunch menu. Whitefish salad is usually a premium deli choice. Turkey is the safest order for a group because it works with many toppings and does not feel too heavy.

Hot Sandwich and Specialty Sandwich Prices

Hot sandwiches and specialty sandwiches sit near the top of the lunch menu. They often come with stronger builds, melted cheese, grilled vegetables, cutlets, corned beef, bacon, dressing, or sauces. These are the orders that make a bagel shop feel like a small deli kitchen.

Grilled cheese is the lower-cost hot sandwich. BLT is a simple classic. Cheesesteak and chopped cheese give a heavier lunch at a middle price. The Reuben Specialty Sandwich is one of the highest-priced lunch items, but it also brings hot corned beef, Swiss, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing. It is a full deli sandwich, not just a quick snack.

Burgers and Heavier Lunch Prices

Some Bagelsmith menus include burgers and other hearty lunch items. These work for guests who are eating with bagel fans but want something closer to a diner meal. Burgers may come with fries or a side salad depending on the menu channel.

The turkey burger is a good pick for a leaner lunch. The Angus burger is a stronger diner-style order. Chopped cheese brings New York deli-counter energy, with beef, cheese, and toppings tucked into a warm sandwich. These meals cost more than a bagel with spread, but they can stand alone as lunch.

Sides and Extras Price List

Sides can change the meal fast. A hash brown or fries can turn an egg sandwich into a breakfast plate. A pickle, chips, fruit cup, or yogurt cup can round out lunch without adding another sandwich.

Hash browns are the best low-cost hot side. Coleslaw, macaroni salad, and potato salad are small add-ons for lunch sandwiches. Home fries and French fries cost more, but they make sense with burgers, chicken sandwiches, and breakfast plates. Tater tots are a good middle pick on the Union, NJ-style menu.

Pastry and Snack Prices

Bagelsmith also sells bakery items and snacks. These can change by day, but common listings include muffins, Danish, cookies, bars, brownies, yogurt cups, fruit cups, and packaged snacks. Pastries are easy add-ons for coffee orders or office trays.

A muffin or Danish pairs well with coffee when a bagel feels too heavy. Packaged bars are cheaper and easier to carry. Cookies cost more on some menus, but they work as a sweet finish after a sandwich.

Coffee, Espresso, and Tea Prices

Coffee is a natural partner for bagels. Some Bagelsmith shops offer simple hot coffee and tea, while others add espresso drinks, lattes, matcha, frappes, and specialty drinks. A coffee box is best for meetings or group breakfast orders.

Hot coffee is the basic pick. Lattes and cappuccinos cost more but feel smoother and richer. Specialty matcha, frappe, and flavored latte drinks sit near the top of the drink list. A coffee box is not for one person, but it is handy for a team breakfast or small event.

Juice, Smoothie, and Cold Drink Prices

The cold drink menu can be long, especially on delivery pages. It may include bottled water, soda, iced tea, juice, coconut water, kombucha, energy drinks, smoothies, matcha drinks, and fresh-squeezed orange juice. These drinks can add several dollars to the total, so they are worth checking before checkout.

Soda and basic bottled water are the lowest-cost cold drinks. Fresh orange juice and smoothies cost much more, but they can make breakfast feel brighter. Smoothies with banana, berries, peanut butter, protein, almond milk, mango, pineapple, coconut water, acai, avocado, and greens appear on some Brooklyn menus.

Best Value Orders at Bagelsmith

The best low-cost order is a single bagel or egg on a bagel. A bagel with cream cheese costs more, but it is still the best basic Bagelsmith meal because it tastes like the shop’s main craft. If you want a hot meal, the egg on a bagel sandwich is the smartest low-price pick.

For a filling breakfast, The Classic or a bacon, egg, and cheese gives a better return than a pastry alone. The Bagelsmith Burrito is strong for a bigger appetite because it includes a hash brown, avocado, egg, cheese, and protein. For a premium breakfast, order The Uptown Lox or build a lox sandwich.

For lunch, the BLT and grilled cheese keep the bill lower. Chicken salad, tuna salad, turkey, cheesesteak, chopped cheese, and chicken cutlet sandwiches cost more but can replace a full lunch elsewhere. For a splurge, the Reuben Specialty Sandwich is one of the strongest picks. It is salty, warm, rich, and built like a deli lunch with shoulders.

For groups, choose a half dozen, Smith’s Dozen, or Smith Pack. Add plain cream cheese and veggie cream cheese for easy sharing. Add a coffee box when the order is for an office or morning event. It keeps the table simple: bagels, spreads, coffee, napkins, and no one asking where breakfast is.

Ordering Tips Before You Go

Choose the bagel first, then choose the spread or filling. Everything bagels match well with cream cheese, eggs, bacon, lox, and turkey. Plain bagels are best when you want the filling to lead. Cinnamon raisin works better with butter or sweet spreads than tuna or pastrami.

Delivery prices may be higher than pickup prices. Some menus also show app-only fees or altered pricing. Large orders should be checked by phone or through the shop’s own ordering page. For catering, order early and pick a mix of plain, everything, sesame, poppy, cinnamon raisin, and whole wheat so the group has enough choice without making the order messy.

Final Thoughts on Bagelsmith Menu Prices

Bagelsmith menu prices usually start around $1.50 to $1.95 for a single bagel and rise through cream cheese bagels, egg sandwiches, lox sandwiches, deli sandwiches, specialty sandwiches, drinks, and group packs. A bagel with cream cheese can sit around $5.75. Egg sandwiches often land around $5.50 to $12.50. Omelettes and platters can run from about $7.15 to $16.69. Specialty sandwiches can reach around $19.25, and bulk bagel packs can move past $30 when spreads are included.

The best first order is a toasted bagel with cream cheese or a classic egg sandwich. The best premium breakfast is a lox sandwich. The best heavy lunch is the Reuben or chicken cutlet specialty sandwich. The best group order is a Smith’s Dozen or Smith Pack with coffee. Bagelsmith works because it covers the whole arc of a busy day: a quick bagel at sunrise, a loaded sandwich at lunch, and a coffee that keeps the wheels turning.