Anthony’s Pizzeria Restaurant Menu and Price List

Anthony’s Pizzeria is the kind of pizza shop that makes dinner feel easy. The smell of baked dough, bubbling cheese, garlic, sausage, pepperoni, and tomato sauce hits first. Then comes the choice: thin crust, double dough, deep dish, stuffed pizza, pasta, wings, sandwiches, salads, and sides. It is comfort food with a red-sauce heartbeat.

This Anthony’s Pizzeria menu and price list gives a helpful look at common items and current public prices from select Anthony’s Pizzeria menus. Because several restaurants use this name, prices can change by location. Use this as a practical guide before ordering.

For readers building a serious pizza setup at home, high-end Amazon picks can include an Ooni Karu 16 pizza oven, KitchenAid commercial stand mixer, Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro, Le Creuset Dutch oven set, and a Vitamix blender for sauces. Together, those picks can pass $2,000. Use Amazon affiliate tag ff42-20 when creating product links.

Popular Menu Items

Thin Crust Pizza

Thin crust is the classic choice. It gives you crisp edges, melted cheese, and sauce without too much bread in the way. The 12 inch works for one or two light eaters. The 16 inch is a strong family size. The 20 inch is the table-filler, the pizza box that barely fits through the door.

Double Dough Pizza

Double dough is for guests who want more chew. The crust is thicker than thin crust, so it holds up well under extra cheese, sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, peppers, or olives. It feels heavier and more filling, like the pizza has put on a winter coat.

Deep Dish Pan Pizza

Deep dish pan pizza has more body than thin crust. The crust is thicker, the slice is softer in the middle, and the edges can take on a golden crunch. It is a good pick for diners who want pizza that feels closer to a full meal.

Stuffed Pizza

Stuffed pizza is the heaviest pizza style on the menu. Cheese and sauce sit inside a thicker build, giving each slice more pull and weight. This is not the pizza you order when you want a quick snack. It is a sit-down, loosen-the-belt kind of pie.

Specialty Pizzas

Anthony’s Monster Pizza is the big one. It is made for people who want toppings stacked high and flavor coming from every corner. A pizza like this works best for groups because each slice carries real weight.

BLT Pizza takes a diner sandwich idea and puts it on a crust. Bacon, mayonnaise, lettuce, and tomato make it different from a regular red-sauce pizza. It is cool, salty, creamy, and crisp all at once.

Common Pizza Toppings

For a safe group order, pepperoni and sausage are the easiest toppings. For a lighter pie, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers work well. Extra cheese makes the pizza richer, but it also makes each slice heavier.

Appetizers and Sides

Appetizers make the pizza order feel bigger. Mozzarella sticks are crisp outside and stretchy inside. Chicken tenders are mild and easy to share. Wings bring heat, salt, and sauce to the table before the pizza arrives.

Pasta and Italian Dinners

The pasta menu gives Anthony’s Pizzeria a full Italian dinner side. Spaghetti, penne, fettuccini, tortellini, stuffed shells, lasagna, and chicken Parmesan are warm, saucy, and filling. Baked pasta costs a little more, but melted cheese gives the dish a richer top layer.

House lasagna and chicken Parmesan are the heavier dinner picks. They cost more than plain pasta, but they feel more complete. Lasagna brings layers, while chicken Parmesan gives crisp chicken, sauce, and cheese on one plate.

Sandwiches, Subs, and Grinders

Sandwiches are the right move when you want Anthony’s flavor without ordering a full pizza. Meatball sandwiches bring sauce and cheese in a soft roll. Chicken Parmesan sandwiches give you the same comfort as the dinner plate, only easier to eat by hand.

Salads

Salads help balance a heavy pizza order. A garden salad is simple and fresh. Caesar salad is creamier and saltier. Greek salad adds feta, olives, and sharper dressing. Antipasto salad is the most deli-like choice, often with meats, cheese, and vegetables.

Best Value Orders

The best value is usually a large thin crust cheese pizza. It feeds more people than a pasta plate or sandwich and stays lower in price than specialty or stuffed pies. A 16 inch thin crust cheese pizza at about $20.25 is a smart middle-ground order.

For bigger hunger, double dough or deep dish makes sense because each slice is more filling. For groups, Anthony’s Monster Pizza can be worth the higher price because it brings more toppings and turns the pizza into the main event.

For a single diner, pasta or a sandwich may be easier than ordering a whole pizza. Spaghetti, penne, baked pasta, meatball sandwiches, and chicken Parmesan are practical solo meals.

What to Order First

First-time guests should start with a thin crust cheese pizza or sausage pizza. That gives a clean taste of the crust, sauce, and cheese. Add mozzarella sticks or wings if you want a fuller table.

For a heavier meal, choose stuffed pizza or deep dish pan pizza. For a specialty order, try Anthony’s Monster Pizza. For pasta, choose baked penne, lasagna, or chicken Parmesan.

Anthony’s Pizzeria Price Summary

Closing Note

Anthony’s Pizzeria is a strong pick for pizza night because the menu gives you many paths. You can keep it simple with thin crust cheese, go heavier with double dough, deep dish, or stuffed pizza, or make the table louder with Monster Pizza, wings, pasta, and sandwiches.

The safest first order is a 16 inch thin crust cheese pizza with one topping. The best heavy order is stuffed pizza. The best group order is Anthony’s Monster Pizza with appetizers. However you order, expect warm dough, melted cheese, red sauce, and the steady comfort of a classic neighborhood pizzeria.